Huisgenoot and YOU have been planning something special for Breast Cancer Awareness month (October) for a while, and it seems like they’re good efforts have (unfortunately) blown up in their faces… By reading the comments on other websites, and their own Facebook pages (You can view dozens of comments below!), it seems like either people think these celebrities really shaved their heads, or the gesture is a ‘complete slap in the face of real cancer patients/survivors’, and another third of people who support Huisgenoot / YOU and the personalities who took part in it.
UPDATE: Read YOU editor Linda Pietersens’ response to the all of this, below. (I find it interesting that nowhere in any of the articles or responses, is any mention made of Huisgenoot who did exactly the same campaign…)
For YOU the participants were:
- Lee-Ann Liebenberg (on the cover)
- Shashi Naidoo
- Poppy Ntshongwana
- Elma Postma (also in Huisgenoot)
- Zakeeya Patel
- LeAnne Dlamini
For Huisgenoot the participants were:
- Elma Postma (on the cover, see below)
- Donnalee Roberts
- Therese Benade
- Lee-Ann Liebenberg (also in YOU)
For some background context, I’ll include the letters of the editors:
Unfortunately all their efforts to show the positive side of what they’re trying to do, has been thrown right back at them… Lee-Ann Liebenberg even went as far as also commenting on YOU’s Facebook page to give some context:
But unfortunately, as it’s the times we’re in currently, anyone and everyone can say exactly what they think and feel, and sometimes without having all the facts. I’ve included some of the comments (mix of Afrikaans and English, for and against, and those who are confused…), from the Channel24 article, but mainly from social media:
I doubt they’ll be doing something similar again in the near future… even though I really think they did it for the greater good; for Cancer Awareness.
But as the last comment reads… “YOU should have first spoken to several cancer sufferers in order to ascertain how they would view pictures that were photoshopped showing celebrities with shaved heads…It might have avoided emotional hurt between cancer sufferers, the general public and the celebrities who probably did not realize the distress it would cause.”.
A good point, and something I think many magazine publishers can learn from this situation…
702’s Heroes and Zeros
YOU’s 23 October issue caused great debate in the past few days. Here editor Linda Pietersen responds to those who were hurt and offended by it.
We are very sorry we offended some cancer survivors and their family members with our cancer awareness campaign. The magazine often covers heartbreaking news stories related to cancer but for breast cancer awareness month we wanted to do something different, something that would really make everyone sit up and take note. And this is exactly what has happened.
Unfortunately, a lot of it has been negative and it was certainly not our intention to hurt anyone or mock people with cancer, as some of our critics put it. Our intention was always to raise awareness for the Cancer Association of South Africa – and this campaign certainly has succeeded in doing just that even if some of it was accompanied by criticism towards us.
Before going ahead we consulted CANSA, which fully endorsed our campaign. They have been as taken aback as we have by some of the negative reaction to the YOU story, pointing out that they’ve partnered in this type of campaign before with another big magazine, which received a positive response from the public.
Although generally social media commenters veer toward the negative there have been positive responses too. Many readers have called in and emailed us applauding our campaign. Many thanked us for putting this terrible disease in the spotlight. Many told us how it had moved them and reminded them of the loved ones they’ve lost or are fighting cancer right now.
So many critics have said we should’ve used real cancer survivors for the story but the reality is celebrities have much greater pull. For example, we had a woman on our cover recently who died of cancer. Her doctor husband wrote a piece so heartrending it moved many of us to tears – yet it barely raised any awareness and certainly didn’t have people flocking to support CANSA.
That’s why we decided to ask celebrities to do this with us. And because their image is their livelihood and their hair is an integral part of their public image we opted to digitally remove their hair.
Some people said our article was misleading because they thought the celebs had really shaved their hair but at no stage did we pretend that was the case. It was stated clearly in the editor’s letter and in the copy that it was digitally removed.
Critics also pointed out that these celebs are shallow and asked what they know of suffering and cancer. Well, almost all of the celebs who took part have been touched by cancer in some way. Cover star Lee-Ann Liebenberg, for example, dedicated her shoot to her father, Allen, who battled lymph and lung cancer, Zaakeya’s grandmother battled breast cancer and Shashi lost an aunt and uncle to the disease.
Like it, or hate, this campaign has got people talking about cancer and that was always our objective. The magazine will continue to bring its readers stories about cancer, be they tragic, triumphant or informative. Together we can fight this terrible disease.
Other related articles:
- IOL: Outrage over ‘bald’ celebs campaign
- EWN: YOU Magazines cancer campaign gets backlash
- EWN: YOU Magazine responds to cancer campaign backlash
- BizCommunity: Too bold or not bald enough?
- CityBuzz: Outrage over YOU Magazines ‘bald’ celebs
- CityBuzz: Scathing attach on YOU Magazines ‘bald’ celebs (This posts includes pictures of some of the photoshopped images)
- East Coast Radio: Outcry over YOU’s ‘bald celeb’ cancer campaign